יום ראשון

Omer Page

The 3rd Beth HaMikdash can be build on Yomtov or Shabboth or at night before the Omer. Is Sefrira Min HaTorah nowadays?

Statisitcs of the Sefer Torah


סדר 
פרשה
שורות
בספר
פרשיות
פתוחות
סתומות
פסוקים
מילים
אותיות
מצות
עשה
לא תעשה
1
241
23
10
13
146
1931
7235
1
1
0

2
230
18
5
13
153
1681
6907
0
0
0

3
208
7
3
4
126
1686
6336
1
1
0

4
252
6
4
2
147
2085
7862
0
0
0

5
171
4
3
1
105
1402
5314
0
0
0

6
173
4
2
2
106
1432
5426
0
0
0

7
235
1
0
1
148
2021
7512
0
0
0

8
237
9
3
6
153
1976
7458
1
0
1

9
190
4
3
1
112
1558
5972
0
0
0

10
155
1
1
0
146
2022
7914
0
0
0

11
178
3
0
3
106
1480
5680
0
0
0

12
148
12
7
5
85
1158
4448
0
0
0

13
215
7
6
1
124
1763
6762
0
0
0

221
16
8
8
121
1748
6701
0
0
0

15
207
14
8
6
106
1655
6149
20
9
11

16
215
14
9
5
116
1681
6423
1
0
1

17
138
15
5
10
75
1105
4022
17
3
14

18
185
33
6
27
118
1462
5313
53
23
30

19
155
9
3
6
96
1145
4692
3
2
1

20
180
10
2
8
101
1412
5430
7
4
3

21
245
14
10
4
139
2002
7424
9
4
5

22
211
13
7
6
122
1558
6181
1
0
1

23
160
20
6
14
92
1182
4432
0
0
0

24
215
21
13
8
111
1673
6222
16
11
5

25
169
8
7
1
97
1353
5096
18
9
9

26
158
6
3
3
91
1238
4670
17
6
11

27
128
9
5
4
67
1010
3667
7
5
2

28
159
6
3
3
90
1274
4697
11
11
0

29
154
15
3
12
80
1170
4294
28
2
26

30
109
4
3
1
64
868
3229
51
13
38

31
217
17
11
6
124
1614
6106
63
24
39

32
99
7
1
6
57
737
2817
24
7
17

33
131
5
3
2
78
1013
3992
12
7
5

34
263
30
23
7
159
1823
7393
0
0
0

35
311
26
18
8
176
2264
8632
18
7
11

36
240
16
11
5
136
1840
7055
5
3
2

37
198
10
7
3
119
1540
5820
3
2
1

38
184
13
7
6
95
1409
5325
9
5
4

39
160
10
6
4
87
1245
4670
3
3
0

40
178
2
1
1
104
1455
5357
0
0
0

41
280
35
10
25
168
1887
7853
6
6
0

42
190
9
4
5
112
1484
5652
2
1
1

43
189
8
6
2
132
1461
5773
6
2
4

44
197
5
1
4
105
1548
5972
2
0
2

45
249
21
5
16
122
1878
7343
12
8
4

46
232
10
6
4
111
1747
6865
8
6
2

47
258
20
5
15
126
1932
7442
55
17
38

48
192
18
3
15
97
1523
5590
41
14
27

49
213
44
2
42
110
1582
5856
74
27
47

50
233
21
5
16
122
1747
6811
6
3
3

51
87
4
1
3
40
657
2575
0
0
0

52
72
3
2
1
30
553
2123
2
2
0

53
92
3
3
0
52
614
2326
0
0
0

54
90
10
2
8
41
512
1969
0
0
0

סה"כ
673
291
382
5846
79796
304785
613
248
365

יום חמישי

Hen that Crowed




 

 SLAUGHTERING A HEN THAT CROWED LIKE A ROOSTER
Superstition link Goral haigros 

QUESTION:
The Gemara says that one is prohibited to say, "Slaughter this hen which crowed like a rooster!" because it is Darchei Emori. In TZAVA'AS RABEINU YEHUDAH HA'CHASID (printed at the beginning of SEFER CHASIDIM, #50), the Chasid writes that if a hen crowed like a rooster, one should slaughter it immediately. Similarly, any other strange object should be removed from one's house.
How can he command that such a hen be slaughtered when the Gemara here says that it is prohibited to do so because of Darchei Emori? 

ANSWERS:

(a) The MAHARIL (Teshuvos #111) says that he asked this question to the Vienna Rosh Yeshiva, Rav Avraham [Klausner], who answered that one is permitted to slaughter the hen as long as he does not say the reason why he is doing so ("because it crowed like a rooster").

A similar answer is given by the MAHARSHA in Chulin (95b) and the SHILTEI GIBORIM in Avodah Zarah (9a of the pages of the Rif). This is cited as the Halachah by the REMA (YD 179:3).
RAV REUVEN MARGOLIYOS (in HAGAHOS MEKOR CHESED on Tzava'as Rabeinu Yehudah ha'Chasid) points out that this approach may be inferred from the words of the Gemara itself. The Gemara does not say that "one who slaughters a hen" transgresses the prohibition of Darchei Emori, but rather "one who says, 'Slaughter this hen...'" transgresses. This implies that only saying the reason for slaughtering the bird is forbidden, but not the actual act of slaughtering.

(b) The VILNA GA'ON (YD 179) disputes this explanation. He argues that, on the contrary, one who slaughters the hen without saying the reason shows that he is trying to fool Hash-m, as it were. His silence makes his act worse, and not better. The Vilna Ga'on, therefore, sides with the Maharil's own answer, which is that Rabeinu Yehudah ha'Chasid had a different text in his Gemara. His Gemara read, "Ein Bo Mishum Darchei ha'Emori" -- "there is no Darchei Emori involved with this act." This reading is also cited by the RASHBA (Teshuvos 1:413), and the KESEF MISHNEH cites it in the name of the RAMACH. It is evident from Rashi, too, that there was such a reading, which he precludes in his comments here.

(c) RABEINU YEHUDAH HA'CHASID himself explains in SEFER HA'KAVOD (a manuscript which included the Tzava'os, which was lost until recently, cited by Hagahos Mekor Chesed and by the new Teshuvos Maharil) explains that even though the Gemara says that it is Darchei Emori, nevertheless anything strange that happens is meant to arouse a person to do Teshuvah and serve as a warning sign that he should do Teshuvah lest something bad happen to him.
It is not clear how this statement answers the question.

RAV REUVEN MARGOLIYOS (ibid.) explains that this means that if a person slaughters the hen for no reason other than the fact that it crowed like a rooster, this is Darchei Emori. If, however, he slaughters the hen for an entirely different reason, then it is not Darchei Emori. In this case, if he slaughters the hen to arouse himself to do Teshuvah by reminding himself of the day of death, and he recognizes that the hen's crowing is a sign from Hash-m that he must do Teshuvah, then it is permitted.

(d) RAV YOSEF ENGEL (in TESHUVOS BEN PORAS) suggests another answer based on similar logic. He says that Darchei Emori is prohibited only when a person's intention is to slaughter the hen because that is what the Nochrim do. Rabeinu Yehudah ha'Chasid saw that many Jews slaughtered hens because the Nochrim did so, and they thereby transgressed the prohibition of Darchei Emori (see Sefer Chasidim, #59). In order to spare them from transgressing, Rabeinu Yehudah ha'Chasid commanded that people slaughter hens that crow like a rooster, so that they would then do so because he commanded it and not because the Nochrim were doing it. In this manner it would no longer be Darchei Emori! 

יום חמישי

מסכת כריתות


שיעורים

הרה"ג רי"ד נ"ש שליט"א
בימ"ד ברזנ"א


מס' כריתות = דף     2    3     4     5     6     7     8     9        10
11   12   13   14   15   16   17


Counter